Repair or Replace: Which is the Best Choice for Your Roof?

Oct 21, 2023Blog, Roof Repair, Roof Replacement, Sandy and Salt Lake City, Should I Repair Or Replace My Roof

When your roof sustains damage, it’s often a tough decision to make—whether to carry out repairs on specific areas or opt for a complete roof replacement. Olympus Roofing, a trusted roofing expert located in Sandy and Salt Lake City, is here to assess your situation and provide valuable guidance in making this important decision.

Of course, you may want to do some preliminary research on your own. Here are some key factors to consider when deciding between repairing or replacing your roof.

roof replacement, roof repair, should I repair or replace my roof, Sandy and Salt Lake City

Age of Roof

Every roofing system has a finite lifespan. For instance, asphalt roofing typically lasts around 20 years, while metal roofing can endure for nearly 50 years. If you notice signs of deterioration on an aging, failing roof, opting for a replacement might be the wiser choice. Continuously repairing the same areas could be a waste of resources.

Leaky Roof

A common reason for contemplating roof repair or replacement is a leak. Pinpointing the exact source of a leak can be quite challenging as water may travel to a different area. Thankfully, the experienced team at Olympus Roofing, located in Sandy and Salt Lake City, is adept at locating areas of damage and can quickly carry out necessary repairs.

Neglecting a leaky roof can lead to additional complications. Mold growth, damaged ceilings, compromised insulation, or rotting structures could all necessitate attention.

The Extent of Damage

When assessing your roof, pay attention to the following warning signs:

  • The roofing material appears worn and aged.
  • Moss, algae, or mildew have started to grow on the surface.
  • Shingles are curled, broken, or cracked.
  • Granules are missing or there are bald spots on the shingles.
  • Metal roofing displays dented areas.
  • Fasteners, shingles, or panels show signs of rust.

Each of these issues should be addressed individually, and based on the extent of the damage, it will become clear whether a repair or a complete replacement is in your future.

roof repair, should I repair or replace my roof, Sandy and Salt Lake City

Improper Ventilation

If you notice condensation on the underside of your roof deck or struggle to maintain a comfortable temperature in your attic or second story during hot summer days, it may indicate inadequate ventilation. This is a vital aspect that can significantly impact the performance of your current roofing system. Proper ventilation not only maintains the roof but can also stem from it.


Undoubtedly, a roof repair is a less expensive option compared to an entirely new roofing system. However, if the damage is extensive, a roof replacement might be the most prudent choice. The final decision will depend on the outcome of the inspection process and the specific findings.

To the untrained eye, a roof might appear to be in good condition. Since most of us do not regularly deal with roofs, it is advisable to consult a reliable roofing contractor like Olympus Roofing in Sandy and Salt Lake City to evaluate your roof’s condition. With our expertise in all things roofing, we can conduct a professional assessment and help you determine the remaining lifespan of your current system. It may well be that a repair is the best immediate option, and we can assist you in planning for a new roof in the future.

At Olympus Roofing, your best interests are at the heart of our service. Don’t hesitate to get in touch for a free consultation to determine whether a roof repair or replacement is the best choice for your unique situation.